How to Tell If You Have Keratoconus vs. Astigmatism

Experiencing blurry vision can be unsettling, and it often leads to questions about the underlying cause. Two common culprits that sometimes get mixed up are keratoconus and astigmatism. While both can impact your visual clarity, they are distinct conditions with different origins, progressions, and treatment approaches. If you’re in Los Angeles or surrounding areas like Newport Beach, Beverly Hills, or Glendale, understanding the difference between keratoconus and astigmatism is the first step towards getting the right care from an experienced eye doctor in Los Angeles.

This guide will walk you through the key characteristics of each condition, highlight their shared symptoms, and, most importantly, help you understand how to differentiate between them so you know when it’s time to seek help from an eye clinic in Los Angeles.

What Is Astigmatism?

Think of your cornea (the clear front surface of your eye) or lens as being smoothly curved like a basketball. In astigmatism, this surface is shaped more like a football, irregularly curved. This irregular shape prevents light from focusing properly on the retina, the light-sensitive tissue at the back of your eye. The result? Blurry vision or distorted vision at all distances, whether you’re looking up close or far away.

Typically, astigmatism is present from birth and often remains relatively stable throughout life. Fortunately, it’s usually easily corrected with standard vision aids such as glasses, soft toric contact lenses designed specifically for astigmatism, or refractive surgery like LASIK.

What Is Keratoconus?

Keratoconus, on the other hand, is a progressive corneal disease. In this condition, the cornea gradually thins and begins to bulge outward into a cone-like shape. This irregular shape severely distorts the way light enters your eye, leading to significant vision problems that often go beyond simple blurriness.

Unlike astigmatism, keratoconus typically develops in teenagers or young adults and tends to worsen over time. It can cause increased light sensitivity, glare, and even double vision. While it might initially mimic severe astigmatism, the progressive nature and the corneal deformation distinguish it. Keratoconus symptoms and treatment in Los Angeles often require more specialized approaches, such as rigid gas-permeable (RGP) or scleral contact lenses, corneal collagen cross-linking (CXL) to halt progression, or, in advanced cases, a corneal transplant.

Shared Symptoms Between Keratoconus and Astigmatism

It’s easy to see why people might confuse these two conditions, as they share some common symptoms: blurry vision, eye strain or fatigue, headaches, poor night vision, and light sensitivity. The shared experience of blurry vision arises because both conditions interfere with the cornea’s ability to properly focus light onto the retina. In astigmatism, this typically stems from an oval or irregularly shaped cornea, causing light to focus on multiple points.

Similarly, in keratoconus, the cone-like bulging of the cornea also distorts the passage of light, leading to a blurred and often distorted image. This fundamental disruption in how light is refracted is the root cause of this shared visual disturbance.

Furthermore, the eye strain or fatigue and associated headaches common to both conditions often result from the visual system working harder to compensate for the imperfect focus. When the cornea isn’t uniformly smooth and spherical, the eye muscles strain in an attempt to achieve clearer vision. This constant effort can lead to feelings of tiredness in the eyes and even manifest as headaches.

Likewise, poor night vision and increased light sensitivity are shared challenges. The irregular corneal surface in both astigmatism and keratoconus can scatter incoming light more than a normally shaped cornea. This scattering reduces visual clarity in dim lighting and can cause glare and discomfort in bright environments, making tasks like night driving more difficult.

Key Differences Between Keratoconus and Astigmatism

To truly understand if you might have keratoconus or astigmatism, let’s look at their fundamental differences:

FeatureAstigmatismKeratoconus
CauseIrregular corneal or lens shapeProgressive thinning and deformation of the cornea
ProgressionTypically stable over timeProgressively worsens and often requires advanced care
OnsetOften present from childhoodCommonly starts during teenage years or early adulthood
TreatmentGlasses, soft contacts, or refractive surgeryRigid/scleral lenses, CXL, or transplant
DiagnosisStandard eye examsSpecialized testing like corneal topography

Also Read: Keratoconus & Vision Loss: An Ophthalmologist’s Guide to Prevention

Signs You Might Have Keratoconus Instead of Regular Astigmatism

While a comprehensive eye exam is the only way to know for sure, certain signs might suggest you should consult an eye specialist in LA for a potential keratoconus evaluation:

  • Frequent changes in your prescription: If your vision correction needs are changing rapidly, it could be a sign of the progressive nature of keratoconus.
  • Glasses don’t fully correct your vision: Unlike typical astigmatism, glasses may not provide satisfactory clarity for someone with keratoconus.
  • Descriptions of “irregular” astigmatism from your eye doctor.
  • Poor contact lens tolerance: Standard soft contact lenses may become uncomfortable or not provide clear vision.
  • Double vision or “ghosting” in one eye: This is a more common complaint with the irregular corneal shape in keratoconus.

How These Conditions Are Diagnosed

Diagnosing each condition involves specific procedures:

  • Astigmatism: Typically detected during a routine eye exam, which includes refraction (determining your prescription) and visual acuity testing (how well you see at different distances).
  • Keratoconus: Requires more specialized testing. Corneal topography, which maps the curvature of your cornea, and pachymetry, which measures corneal thickness, are important for diagnosis. A slit-lamp evaluation, a microscopic examination of the front of your eye, is also important.

Treatment Options Compared

The treatment approaches for astigmatism and keratoconus differ significantly:

Astigmatism

  • Glasses or soft toric contact lenses are often the first line of correction.
  • Refractive surgery, such as LASIK or PRK, can permanently reshape the cornea to correct astigmatism.

Keratoconus

  • Rigid gas-permeable (RGP) or scleral contact lenses are often necessary to provide clear vision by creating a new, smooth refractive surface.
  • Corneal collagen cross-linking (CXL) is a treatment designed to strengthen the cornea and halt the progression of keratoconus.
  • Intacs (corneal inserts) are small plastic rings that can be surgically placed in the cornea to help reshape it.
  • In severe cases, a corneal transplant may be necessary to replace the damaged cornea with a healthy donor cornea.

When to See an Eye Specialist

It’s essential to consult an eye specialist if you experience any of the following:

  • Rapid changes in your vision or your prescription keep shifting.
  • Your glasses no longer provide sharp vision.
  • You’ve been told you have “irregular” astigmatism.
  • You have a family history of keratoconus.
  • You are considering LASIK or another vision correction procedure and have any of the above symptoms.

For those in the Los Angeles area looking for the best eye specialist for keratoconus in Los Angeles, it’s important to find a clinic with expertise in corneal diseases and access to advanced diagnostic and treatment technologies. Whether you’re in Los Angeles, Newport Beach, Beverly Hills, or Glendale, understanding your vision problems is the first step towards effective management.

If you’re concerned about blurry vision or suspect you might have keratoconus or a more complex form of astigmatism, don’t hesitate to seek a comprehensive eye evaluation from a qualified eye doctor at Soroudi Advanced LASIK and Eye Centers. Early diagnosis and appropriate management are key to maintaining the best possible vision.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *